Rate of Reinforcement

Rate of reinforcement is a number of rewards per amount of time.

Traditional positive training says that you should shoot for 15-30 rewards per minute for learning and tough challenges. That’s a cookie every 2-4 seconds. A high rate of reinforcement of success creates a snowball effect. It becomes easier and easier to succeed. Successful performance of a behavior becomes habit.

Rate of Reinforcement is a tool that you can use to:

  • contrast performance with non-performance
  • contrast quality performance vs poor performance
  • contrast excellent performance with quality
  • add value
  • extinguish behaviors
  • control energy level of training session

Contrasting Performance

It’s OK if your dog is not doing the behavior for a few moments (or even a minute or two) if you contrast that non-performance and lack of reinforcement with awesome stuff when the behavior is happening. The contrast between a high rate of reinforcement for good stuff and no reinforcement for not so good stuff is unmistakeable communication.

Using rate of reinforcement strategically to your advantage is a key for creating behaviors, upping the ante, and fading cookies and will help you and your dog overcome challenges.

Adjusting Value and Extinguishing Behavior

A high rate of reinforcement will add value to behaviors and situations. You can make your dog really like to do a behavior (operant) or really like to be in a situation (classical) with free-flowing cookies. A low rate of reinforcement can reduce value to behaviors and situations especially when distractions are present. Zero reinforcement should extinguish behavior. It certainly will if you add value to an alternate or incompatible behavior.

Low or zero reinforcement can punish behavior.

Controlling Energy Levels

Rate of reinforcement has a close relationship to the energy level of the session. A high rate of reinforcement often means high energy. A low rate of reinforcement often means low energy. Manipulating the rate of reinforcement can and will manipulate the energy levels of your training session as well as the performance of behaviors.

The pace you and your dog work can become a habit. Nothing is more frustrating than trying to work a down with a dog who is working feverishly. It is fairly easy to condition your dog to need a high rate of reinforcement.

Success is Contagious

Related Articles

Pawsitive Vybe S2E5 – Rate of Reinforcement

Rate of Reinforcement is well understood in dog training. We consider it one of the Four Principles of Positive Dog Training. Below we focus on Rate of Reinforcement as Cookies Per Minute (CPM) via some training and disc dog jam sessions and relate Rate of Reinforcement to the teaching, handling, and performance of dogs.

Patron’s Choice: Shaping a Leaping Catch | Creating a Late Read

Reading the disc is a skill that astute dogs and humans pick up rather quickly. The float, the spin, and the speed can reliably be gauged and predicted after several reps. Of course this changes with wind, disc choice, and throwing ability but, generally speaking, the flight path of a disc is easily predicted.


  1. I so agree that rate of reinforcement determines how far a person could go and how great his performance will be. At some point in our lives we do need a constant drive to get us to keep going and getting better at what we do. Otherwise, we sometimes end up in the dead end of disinterest.

    My Blog: chaise enfant 

Comments are closed.